The age-old adage “sometimes one just has to take a side” is often invoked in conflicts where the lines between right and wrong are blurred. But what drives this moral imperative to choose a side, even when the situation is unclear? The answer lies in the distinction between “sins of commission” and “sins of omission.” While we tend to view acts of commission as more morally culpable, omissions can be just as grievous. For instance, failing to save a drowning child is a morally reprehensible act, just as pouring petrol through a letterbox and setting a house on fire is.
When faced with a conflict, we often find it easier to sit on the fence, rather than choosing a side and risking being wrong. However, this approach ignores the fact that not choosing a side is, in itself, a choice. By opting out of taking a stance, we may inadvertently be supporting the wrong side, thereby committing a moral omission. The likelihood of both sides being equally right or wrong is slim, and by not choosing a side, we risk tacitly supporting the side that is in the wrong.
This concept is further complicated by the fact that conflicts often have far-reaching implications beyond the immediate issue at hand. For example, choosing to support one side over the other may prevent future harm or conflict. Ultimately, the decision to take a side is not just about making an arbitrary choice, but about serving one’s own intellectual integrity and honesty.
The notion that we must take a side, even when the situation is unclear, is rooted in the understanding that moral equality between two sides is unlikely. By not judging which side is right or wrong, we risk supporting the wrong side by default. In essence, not taking a side is not a morally neutral act, but rather a choice that can have significant moral consequences. As we navigate complex conflicts, it is essential to recognize that our choices, or lack thereof, can have far-reaching implications. By acknowledging the moral imperatives at play, we can make more informed decisions that align with our values and principles.
https%3A%2F%2Fdaily-philosophy.com%2Fjohn-shand-taking-a-side%2F
No Comments